It’s always interesting watching the competition in the late night talk show world. That time slot has been a classic part of America’s television watching routine for about a half a century. And right now, there’s been something of a shakeup there.
In the last couple years, we have seen a massive turnover of hosts on all the shows. Jimmy Fallon took over the legendary “Tonight Show” on NBC, Stephen Colbert moved into “The Late Show” at CBS and Jimmy Kimmel was the latest host to take on the time slot for ABC. Of the three of them, the one who was watched with the greatest anticipation had to be Stephen Colbert.
Colbert was coming off a superstar turn as the host of Comedy Central’s “Colbert Report”. He was a super hot property and CBS was looking for a host to improve on the ratings of long-time host David Letterman. Colbert’s core cable audience was young, hip and, oh yeah, young. This was going to shake things up in the late night arena.
Colbert won the ratings battle his opening week but didn’t hold the lead at all. In fact, at one point in December Colbert was in the number four ratings slot behind Fallon, Kimmel and NBC’s Seth Myers, whose show comes on AFTER the major late night offerings.
So it is perhaps unsurprising that the network has brought in a new lead producer, what the industry refers to as a “showrunner”. Chris Licht, who had been the executive producer for the network’s morning program “CBS This Morning”, has now been handed the reins for “Late Night”.
Overall, Colbert’s number have grown year to year but haven’t significantly improved on Letterman. He is in a close battle with Kimmel for second place most weeks.
I’m not a huge consumer of late night TV. I tend to judge the success of a show by how often my social media friends share a clip, a line or a bit from the shows in their feeds. I see Kimmel regularly. Colbert’s appearances in the last year wouldn’t require the fingers of one hand to count.
When Stephen Colbert made the move away from “The Colbert Report”, he announced he was leaving that character behind as well. At the time, I wondered how much that might hurt his connection with his audience. The network scores the most overall viewers of all networks most weeks and finishes second with the desirable 18-49 demographic. So it’s not as if Colbert was having to manufacture potential viewers.
My bet is that until he regains some of that cutting edge, iconoclastic personality that made him a cable sensation, no amount of showrunner tweaking is going to set the late night on fire.
Leave a comment