On Books – E versus DTB

The amount of energy that gets expended on the debate between E-books and traditional (DTB – Dead Tree Books) always amazes me. Because there’s not really a “debate” to be had. There is a clear and simple answer to the question. I’ll get to that in a minute.

If you read through the threads, it comes down to a simple concept most times. “I prefer…” That’s it. Whatever that reader likes is what they think is best. Which is fine but hardly the basis for any kind of argument. It’s when “my preference” becomes “the best”, or worse yet “the only”. The level of ego required to make that leap (especially the last one) is impressive. But our culture has a growing inclination to play that game. “If I don’t like it, it’s no good”. Sorry, but as a general rule, WRONG. I don’t like fantasy novels where the author falls in love with their world-building and overwhelms me with details. Even Tolkien falls prey to that. (I skim those bits). There are folks who love it. Good for them. I don’t like most any avant-garde art, in any form. It doesn’t speak to me but it does to others. More power to them. The list goes on.

There are times when I can explain why I think something fails in writing or film or whatever. There are many things that aren’t any good, in my opinion. Sometimes I’m even RIGHT! But “I don’t like it” isn’t ever a compelling argument.

You may prefer all the sensory inputs that come from a traditional book. I will admit to enjoying the physical sensations of the sound and smell of a book. The feeling of the pages as my fingers turn them.

At the same time, I own both a Nook and a Kindle. Both get regular use. The ability to carry dozens of books at once in a single slim, light “volume” is wonderful. I have no trouble reading them, and they are a special joy while traveling.

So, what’s my simple, clear answer to the question of “E vs tree”? Whatever gets someone to open a book. If it works for the reader, this author is all about it. Read on your phone or from a book on your lap. On a screen or a paperback.

The format is unimportant.

As is the debate.

Grab what works for you.

And read.

Peace

Jay